Making a shortlist

Decide what you want from high school

The most useful first step is a family conversation: what do you actually want from these four years?

Updated August 2026

The most useful thing you can do at the start has nothing to do with schools. It's a conversation about what you actually want out of these four years.

It's tempting to skip. The calendar fills up fast with tours, school, and life, and it feels productive to just start looking. But if you haven't agreed on what you're looking for, every school becomes its own pros-and-cons list, and you end up comparing schools against each other instead of against what matters to your family.

What is high school for, for this student?

There's no universal right answer, and that's the point. For some families it's about a career: high school is the path to a certain kind of college, and that college to a certain kind of work. For others it's about discovery, giving a teenager room to figure out who they are and what they care about. Sometimes your student needs a place to grow up a little, to be known and steadied. And sometimes a student already has a passion, a sport or an instrument or a kind of problem they love to chew on, and high school is where they go deeper into it.

Most families have a philosophy, spoken or unspoken, and it can shift subtly from one student to the next. The point of the conversation is to make sure everyone is clear on the goals, so that when you walk through a school you're measuring it against something real instead of a feeling.

If you do this, everything downstream gets easier. The "best" school stops being an abstraction and becomes a specific question. Does this place do well by the thing we said we wanted? That's a question you can carry into every tour, open house, and profile page.

If your family wants a structure for the conversation, the Family Compass walks each of you through the same five minutes of questions, then shows you, side by side, where you agree and where you don't, so you can work toward a definition of what you want that everyone shares.